As i said previously, my biggest problems with the game have nothing to do with the maps. Paris and Sap were awesome maps and even if the rest were just as good or better, there's no way I personally would give the game more than a 7.
I hated epiodic. I'll generously only knock off 1 point.
The AI behavior (accents, wallhacking, minigun pistols, accuracy from 1,000 yards out, spotting you from 1,000 yards out. Another point off. (Generously)
All the other little crap like online-only, bugs up the wazoo, unpolished aspects like the fiber wire, and the list continues. At least another point off.
I don't need to play the whole season to make those judgements. And again, keep in mind, this is simply one guy's opinion so you can't really say it's wrong. But you're certainly allowed to have your own.