House of the Dragon is worthy successor to Game of Thrones so far. Depicting the apex of Targaryen power over the Seven Kingdoms and the war of succession that marked the beginning of their decline, it was actually the potential spin off I was looking forward the least. I can’t remember my internal reasoning at the time (maybe that some of the other stories were more interesting or less known?) but it has acquited itself well.
It evokes what GOT started as and shows the strength of the source material when adapted well. Quick aside, I see GOT as having two distinct epochs which can go at least some way to explaining what happened with the ending; “The Adaptation” of seasons 1-4 and “The Original Series” of seasons 5-8. The height of GOT’s power was when Benioff and Weiss had five thousand page novels at their disposal. After they had exhausted most of that information, they had to rely more and more on just making shit up. I have no doubt that the ending is more or less what GRRM intended but I am equally sure that he will handle it better (should he ever decide to finish “A Song of Ice and Fire”). All this to say that all of the pertinent information regarding the Dance of the Dragons is complete; HOTD is unlikely to worry about passing the novels.
THAT said, this show is based on a faux history book, not a novel series. The series should provide far more accessible to those, unlike me, who aren’t big history buffs and found the original text a bit cumbersome. And the history buffs, like me, should be able to enjoy the characters come to life and tell their stories themselves, rather than just a bunch of historian type characters speculating.
Anyway, it’s been great fun so far; Matt Smith is a standout but the rest of the cast is also very good, the production as high quality as its predecessor and Ramin Djawadi is always great to listen to. The only real knock I have against it is that it can be a bit hard to keep up at times; like its predecessor, its first season is prolonged setup, but unlike its predecessor, it takes place over decades. The main conflict itself only lasted a couple years but it was decades in the making so I appreciate the commitment to the context. I just have to get in the mindset of jumps of months or years between episodes.
To wrap everything up (apologies for the novel length review
), it really does seem to be benefiting from having its source material finished. It knows the beginning, middle and end well enough that it can also provide an extended, and necessary, prologue (and, possibly, an appropriate length epilogue of sorts). I also really like that its dipping into more of the lore from the books. Though, according to the in universe histories, nobody knows what exactly inspired Aegon the Conqueror to begin his conquest, and the dreams in question sound more like those of Prince Rhaegar some 300 years later, I applaud them referencing the song of ice and fire and the prophetic dreams that run in members of House Targaryen. More than that, though, I was probably way more excited than I should have been when they not only explicitly mentioned the Rhoynar but also restored that part of the official title of the monarch. I guess, long story short, I just love how much more detailed it is than Game of Thrones. Although, I’m struggling to see how this results in massive bloodshed; everyone gets along SO well!
