Just binge watched Dexter: Original Sin. When I first heard about this show being made, I was not happy. I was certain it would be a big mistake, they were not going to be able to cast a younger set of actors to play familiar characters that would be believable, and that they’d retcon and convolute the lore all over the place. I can say with relief that I was completely wrong. Here’s my little break down, spoilers for those who’ve never watched any part of this franchise:
Concept
Its status as a prequel was the bedrock issue I had with it when I heard it was coming, but they pulled it off well. The reveal that it’s Dexter’s life flashing before his eyes as he’s resuscitated from what had previously been believed to be a fatal gunshot that closed the book on the series was a welcome surprise, and that it’s to set up another sequel series that will carry on from where the previous ended was a good move. The two previous finale attempts were not well-received (I personally only had one issue with each of them but otherwise found them acceptable as endings), so that they’re trying to do it right a third time and using this series to gin up interest for it was the right call.
Story
The story is the usual Dexter fare, but it still feels fresh. Even though you know what fates await each character, you still feel the tension of the critical situations as you wonder how these events play out so that what happens down the road in the timeline is not impacted by what happened in this unknown past.
Consistency
This was where my biggest concern lie, but I’m glad that it wasn’t even a tenth as bad as I expected. A few inconsistencies showed up here and there, but nothing that can’t be explained away as just the show not bothering showing certain details in order to flesh out everything else that happened that we didn’t previously know, or Dexter’s mind, barely clinging to life, just remembering wrong.
The one change that I did not like is that it made Brian more violent too early. Although not elaborated on and only a small part of his life as a kid was seen in the original series, the implication was that, like Dexter, Brian was a normal and sweet kid who only became unhinged because of the traumatic experience he and Dexter went through. We were led to believe that because Brian was older and more aware, the trauma hit too deeply with him because he couldn’t block it out like the younger Dexter could. This series shows that he was already a mean and aggressive little shit who just crossed over into being truly dangerous after what happened. This takes away from the overall concept that what happened was so bad, both boys were irrevocably changed, making it seem like Brian was already on that path anyway.
Cast
The cast was fantastic. The actors for Dexter and Debra know how to emulate their predecessors’ behaviors to the letter, and Bautista’s actor I would swear was just the original actor digitally de-aged, it was that spot on. Masuka and Laguerta have a similar treatment. I do have one gripe: Christian Slater is not Harry. He looks, sounds, and acts nothing like James Remar’s Harry from the original, and while the version of Harry he’s presenting here is decently acted, it carries none of the feel of the Harry we knew from the original. It was like they were more concerned with getting a big name to play at least one of the familiar characters that they didn’t even try to find someone who seemed like he could be a younger James Remar. Disappointing.
Soundtrack
It stopped being so prominent about halfway through the season, but holy hell, did they have to play every song that was on the top ten of the billboard in 1991 every five minutes? I mean, they were good songs, but it was like they were trying so hard to tell the audience “this is the early 90s!” that they might as well have just had someone say those words in every episode. This whole thing of using lots of famous songs for a soundtrack playing every few minutes can be blamed on Suicide Squad, frankly. I’m pretty sure that movie convinced people that this is an idea that works. Distracting the audience from slow moments in a story with songs they recognize does not improve things, people, it just shows that you’re trying to cover empty space.
Overall, it was a good series, a worthy prequel, and I hope there’s a season 2.